Menus and Ingredient List

 Want to have a cookie party? Tell us how many guests you'll have, and we can come up with the right amount of undecorated sugar cookies, tubes of colored buttercream, and sprinkles to keep the kids (or adults) entertained.  See menu for full pricing.
 

Yes, we make custom buttercream sugar cookies! Some say the most delicious sugar cookies in Indianapolis.   These are sold by the dozen, starting at

2 to 3 inch cookies, $26

4 to 5 inch cookies, $30

Individually wrapped, $3 per dozen

Prices may depend on decor.  These can be made GF, DF, and Vegan.  We can also use natural food coloring.  

See Menu for full pricing.

For Valentine's Day, Easter, and Halloween, we sell sugar cookie kits.   

These include 18 - 3 to 4 inch cookies, 4 - 5 oz tubes of buttercream,  sprinkles, and m&ms, starting at $35. Pre-order yours 2 weeks prior to the holiday.

Featured on a 99.5 ZPL post over the 2020 Holidays, our delicious gingerbread kits become available in November. These include mini-gingerbread houses or larger gingerbread house with additional cookies in festive shapes, royal icing, gumdrops, sprinkles, and m&ms, starting at $25. 

Our signature organic oatmeal, walnut, flax seed, chocolate chip cookies are loaded with Omega-3 fatty acids and some moms swear that oatmeal helps lactation. Any pregnant or nursing mom gets an extra cookie per every dozen ordered. 

$28 per dozen 

$30 per GF dozen 

$32 per vegan dozen

Pre-order for morning pick-up!

Cinnamon Rolls with cream cheese icing, $30

Chocolate Nutella Rolls with cream cheese icing, $34

Chocolate or butterscotch scones, $22

Lemon blueberry scone with lemon icing, $24  

Between October and March, when the humidity is low, we make our famous salted butter pecan toffee. This is a traditional toffee, made with butter, sugar, pecans, sprinkled with chocolate chips, and the right touch of salt. 

$12 for an 8 oz bag, $24 for a 16 oz bag, additional pricing available for larger orders. This makes a great fundraiser! (See our fundraising page.) 

We make three types of keto cookies. These must be ordered by the dozen.

Chocolate Pixies: Chocolate cream cheese mini-keto brownie bites, $20

Fat Snowballs: Toasted cashews and peanuts, almond flour, and peanut butter make these decadent keto cookies one of our best sellers. Dusted with powdered sugar, you won't realize these are less than gram of net carbs, $24

Pecan Shortbread: Freshly chopped pecans make these naturally sweet and delicious. These are also GF, $20

We don't use fondant, we decorate our cakes with our custom buttercream sugar cookies.  These unique cakes are quirky fun crowd pleasers.  We will put any of our cookies on a cake, stack them on top or cover your cake with them.  We can make cookie cakes using a traditional cake or even stacked blondies.  See our menu for full pricing.  And, yes, we do weddings!  And are especially good at making stacked chocolate chip or stacked blondie cakes with layers of buttercream icing in between.  See our menu for full pricing

Over the Winter and Spring Holidays, we Bake it Forward. Please see our FB and IG pages for information. We joyfully give away cookie kits to people or families who are in need of some extra holiday cheer. God blessed us to be blessings to others.

We also work with several organizations for fundraising events. Please contact us and tell us about your event! We believe that God blesses us to be a blessing to others.

If you're looking for fondant cakes, please visit:

Sandy's "Sweet Designs" Shop. She makes marvelous fondant cakes!

317-714-0285

If you're looking for royal icing cookies, please visit:

> Hannah Bakes Custom Cookies: 317-376-7800

> Nic's Cookie Boutique: 317-213-6200